Fibre is not a preference. It is the conclusion of four answers about the part: whether it gets hit, whether it has to insulate or pass a signal, how much the weight matters, and what it is allowed to cost.
What each one is
Both are composites — fibre in a resin matrix. What changes is the fibre.
Carbon fibre is made by carbonising a precursor at high temperature. It is very stiff and strong for its weight, and it fails in a brittle way: it carries load, then breaks, with almost no yielding. Standard-modulus carbon is typically around 230 GPa in modulus and 3,000–5,000 MPa in tensile strength, at about 1.75–1.8 g/cm³ for the fibre and 1.55 g/cm³ for the cured laminate.
Glass fibre — called fiberglass in the US, and E-glass is the common grade — is drawn from molten glass. It is less stiff, around 72–76 GPa, but it stretches much further before breaking: 4–5% strain against 1.5–2% for carbon. It is also denser, around 2.5 g/cm³ for the fibre and 1.8–2.0 g/cm³ for the laminate.
That one difference in strain to failure explains most of the practical behaviour: glass absorbs energy by deforming, carbon stays straight and then fails.
The comparison, in the order that matters
| Property | Carbon fibre | Glass fibre | What it means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stiffness (modulus) | ~230 GPa fibre | ~72–76 GPa | Carbon is roughly three times as stiff in the same section |
| Tensile strength | 3,000–5,000 MPa fibre | 1,500–2,500 MPa | Both are strong; stiffness usually limits first |
| Strain to failure | ~1.5–2% | ~4–5% | Glass deforms before breaking; carbon does not |
| Density (laminate) | ~1.55 g/cm³ | ~1.8–2.0 g/cm³ | Carbon is lighter at equal volume, not at equal stiffness |
| Impact and puncture | Poor — energy becomes cracking | Good — energy becomes deformation | Parts that get hit, dropped or stood on are glass |
| Fatigue | Excellent under tension–tension | Good, at lower absolute stress | Rotating and cyclically loaded parts are carbon |
| Thermal expansion (axial) | Near zero, slightly negative; positive transverse | ~5–6 ×10⁻⁶/K | Dimensional stability under temperature change is carbon |
| Thermal conductivity | Conducts along the fibre | Insulates | Heat paths are carbon; heat barriers are glass |
| Electrical | Conductive | Insulating | Live parts, insulating rods and barriers must be glass |
| Radio | Blocks — a Faraday cage | Transparent | Antenna covers and RF windows must be glass |
| Galvanic couple with aluminium | Yes, in moisture | No | Carbon bolted to aluminium needs a barrier |
| Machining | Cuts cleanly; dust is conductive | Abrasive, wears tooling | Glass costs more at the drill and the saw |
| Surface | Weave visible under clear resin | Translucent, or painted | Appearance parts are usually carbon |
| Cost | High | Low | On large simple parts, material dominates and so does the gap |
Question 1: does the part get hit?
Impact is where the two are furthest apart, and where most mis-specified parts come from. Carbon takes the load, then cracks at the point of impact with almost no warning. Glass bends, whitens, and keeps working.
A housing dragged across a workshop floor, a tray that takes stone chips, a cover that gets stood on, a part that gets knocked during assembly — glass is the right answer for all of these. Carbon can be made to survive them, but only by designing for impact: a thicker wall, glass plies on the loaded face, a tougher resin. Each of those gives back the weight you paid to save.
Where the part is only looked at and never loaded — a fairing, a visible panel, interior trim — the impact question is answered by the geometry, and stiffness and appearance decide it for carbon.
Question 2: does it have to insulate, or pass a signal?
Then it is glass, and there is no trade-off to discuss. A carbon enclosure is a conductor and a Faraday cage: it cannot be an antenna cover, an insulating rod, a barrier in front of a live terminal, or a window for a radio signal.
The same applies at the joint. Carbon in contact with aluminium, with moisture present, sets up a galvanic couple and the aluminium corrodes. A glass ply or sleeve at the interface is the standard fix — cheaper than a coating that has to be maintained.
One property is often forgotten: glass resists acids, alkalis and water. Chemical platforms, grating and parts around plating lines are glass for that reason alone.
Question 3: how much does the weight actually matter?
This decides most projects, and it is usually answered by experience rather than by calculation. On a moving mass — a robot arm, a boom, a reciprocating carriage — every kilogram saved comes back as cycle time, payload or motor size, and carbon earns its price. On a static cover, a base plate or a guard, the same kilogram saves nothing, and glass is the right answer at an order of magnitude less in material cost.
For stiffness-limited parts the gap is smaller than the density numbers suggest: glass needs more material to reach the same stiffness, so part of the weight penalty is bought back. It does not vanish — but the question narrows from “does it work” to “is it worth the price”.
Question 4: what is the budget for this part?
Both fibres use the same processes in the same plant: hand lay-up, vacuum bagging, RTM, pultrusion. The tooling and the equipment do not change. The cost difference is in making the fibre. Glass is drawn from a furnace in one continuous run. Carbon starts as a PAN precursor, then goes through oxidation and carbonisation above a thousand degrees — more steps, more energy, and the precursor alone is over half the cost. In the market, common T300-grade carbon runs at around USD 15 per kilogram, and glass fabric is a small fraction of that (indicative only; raw materials and capacity move these prices, so ask us for a current quote).
On a large flat panel, a bracket or a guard, material is the biggest line, and glass can cut it by half or more. Where the part exists to save weight, the saving itself is the product, and the price is what that saving is worth.
There is a third case: it has to look like carbon without being carbon throughout. A carbon weave on the visible face with glass behind it gives the same appearance at a lower price, at the cost of some weight.
Often the answer is both
Hybrid lay-ups are not a compromise; they are the normal engineering answer when the requirements disagree:
- glass on the impact face, carbon behind it for stiffness
- a glass barrier layer between a carbon part and an aluminium frame
- glass local to bolt holes and bearing points, where carbon would crush
- carbon on the visible face, glass in the structure behind it
What decides performance is the lay-up, not the fibre. The same fibre, stacked in a different order, behaves like a different material.
Four numbers before we quote
- the load, or the deflection the machine allows
- whether it takes impact, and what kind
- whether it has to insulate, conduct or pass a signal
- the annual quantity and the budget
With those four, the fibre, the lay-up and the price follow. Without them, any quote is a guess in one material or the other.
需要可制造性评审? 开始询价