Forming Routes, Chosen by Part

A job travels from drawing to assembly through three stages: forming, post-machining and inspection. Which forming route it takes is decided by shape, by load path and by batch size — not by what equipment you happen to have.

Five lines run here: HP-RTM, compression moulding, filament winding, pultrusion, and LFT-D. Most composite shops run one process, so one job can mean several suppliers. With all five under one roof, a part that changes route does not change supplier. Carbon and glass fibre both run on these lines; which one a part gets is decided by stiffness, cost and the environment, not by the process. Each line has parts it is good at and parts it cannot make. They are taken one at a time below — match your part against them.

A job can also be split: design only, forming only, or post-machining only.

HP-RTM Compression Moulding Filament Winding Pultrusion LFT-D
Typical part 3D closed shells, inserts moulded in Semi-structural, ribs and bosses Bodies of revolution, closed sections Constant-section profiles Highly integrated functional parts
Load direction Multi-directional, set by the lay-up Multi-directional, follows the flow Hoop and torsion Mainly axial Broadly uniform
Tooling spend High Medium to high Low (mandrel) Medium (die) High
The batch it wants Mid batches and up Mid batches and up Mid batches By the metre or by the piece Big runs
Surface Smooth both faces; Class A needs a polished mould and a topcoat One or both faces; Class A needs post-finishing Mandrel surface or machined As it leaves the die As it leaves the mould

HP-RTM

HP-RTM — high pressure resin transfer moulding — is the route for three-dimensional closed shells: the shape is solid, inserts have to be buried in it, and both faces have to be presentable.

The preform is laid up and loaded into the cavity, then resin is injected at pressure. Wet-out is fast and cure is fast: at its fastest a cycle takes three to five minutes, which fits into a production schedule. Consistency is the thing that matters here. Against hand lay-up and vacuum infusion, resin transfer moulding holds fibre volume fraction high and void content low, so the mechanical data is worth relying on; wall thickness repeats, and a batch does not come out one tolerance per part.

But it is choosy about the part. A steel mould and high-pressure injection is a heavy spend, and it will not spread over a short run. The outline lives in the mould: changing the shape means a new mould, not a new machine program. The preform is made here too, starting from incoming material, with nothing sent out — and the complex part of the shape is a step in its own right. Class A appearance does not arrive by itself either: the mould is polished, and a topcoat or an in-mould coating still goes on.

A few things have to be settled before the mould is cut; settle them late and the tool gets reworked. Parting line and draft angle. Where the inserts sit and how they are held — the flow pushes on them, and one pushed out of place is one scrapped part. Where the gate and the vents go — air collects where the flow front meets itself last. Where the wall changes, taper it; do not step it.

Inspection: wall thickness and outline on a CMM, first-off and then sampled; void content and fibre volume fraction by section microscopy or ultrasonic; insert pull-out force and seal-face flatness signed off at first-off.

HP-RTM process: fabric unwinding, cutting and stacking, loading into the mould, preforming, then mould closing with resin injection, curing and mould opening

Compression Moulding

Semi-structural parts that have to come out with ribs, bosses and metal inserts in one shot go to compression moulding. Fibre or moulding compound goes into a heated closed mould; pressure makes the resin flow, wet out and cure, and the ribs and inserts grow with the body, which takes out the assembly step. The more integration a part carries, the better this line pays.

The same mould can take either feed. Prepreg gives the most accurate fibre content and thickness, and the best surface, at the price of expensive material, cold storage and lay-up hours. Wet compression moulding (WCM) lays fabric into the cavity and injects the resin there before closing; it saves the cold chain and the lay-up, but resin content then depends on the operator and the mould, and batch-to-batch spread is wider than on the pre-impregnated route.

Cycle time is quoted per part. A thin part comes out in minutes; with wet compression moulding in epoxy, once the wall has some thickness to it, it runs to forty or fifty minutes — wall thickness and resin system pull it either way.

The trouble is flow. Flow length is finite, and a deep cavity fights a large flat face; the deeper the shape, the more it needs simulation. Fibre orientation follows the flow, so strength comes from a flow study, not from the lay-up. The projected area is capped by press capability and tool stiffness. The surface needs finishing before it reaches Class A, wet moulding especially, where resin content shows up in the appearance. Small batches do not pay here either: the tool is in the same league as HP-RTM.

Before the mould is cut, even out the wall and avoid thick-to-thin steps; work out the rib thickness ratio and the draft; leave material around inserts, since poor encapsulation is a defect waiting to happen; put the parting line on a non-visible face.

Dimensions and warpage on a surface plate or a gauge; fibre distribution and resin-rich zones on sectioned samples; mechanical properties sampled per batch.

Wet compression moulding: fabric unwinding, cutting and stacking, resin spraying and impregnation, mould closing and curing, mould opening

Filament Winding

Parts with a body of revolution or a closed section go to filament winding.

Continuous fibre is wound onto the mandrel at a set angle and cured layer by layer. Change the winding angle and hoop, axial and torsional stiffness all move with it: the same tube at a different angle is a different part. The fibre never gets cut, which is where this route differs most from roll wrapping and pultrusion.

What it cannot do is equally clear. The shape has to come off the mandrel: a taper, a collapsible mandrel, or a soluble one. The surface is the mandrel or a machined face, with the pattern the winding left on it, so it is not an appearance face. Domes, openings and flanges do not exist until they are designed: the ends are their own job. Outside diameter depends on the mandrel and on later machining; the winding pass does not deliver it.

Before winding starts: set the angle and the lay-up sequence from the load spectrum, not from habit; settle the mandrel taper and how the part comes off; decide how far the end reinforcement runs, and which faces carry machining allowance.

Wall thickness and diameter sampled per batch; the pattern and overlap record filed with each batch; pressure or leak testing as agreed per project.

Filament winding: continuous fibre from the creel through the resin bath and tension rollers, laid onto a rotating mandrel

Pultrusion

A section that does not change along the length goes to pultrusion: tube, rod, plate, angle, channel, I-beam and the shapes in between.

Continuous fibre is impregnated, pulled through a heated die and cured in line; what comes out is the finished section. The fibre runs axially and is never cut, which gives the highest axial efficiency of the five routes. Pricing by the metre or by the piece keeps unit cost down. Where insulation or corrosion resistance is wanted and the budget is per metre, this is usually the route.

Its limits all come from one word: constant. The section cannot change along the length; a change means a new die or a machined part. Wall thickness is set by the die, so a new wall is a new die. Transverse strength is below axial, so hoop load needs mat or a move to winding. The surface is the die surface: gloss and Class A do not come from this line.

It is cheap, and it is a standard product. Asking custom-part tolerance and finish at pultrusion prices is the most common mistake in this category. The one that causes the most argument at quotation.

Before the die is cut: fix the section and wall, and do not hold a machinable feature to the forming tolerance; set length from transport and cutting; keep holes, slots and threads in the machining step rather than in the die; join by bonding or interference fit, with bond-line thickness allowed on the mating face.

Section size and straightness sampled per batch, with a dimensional report; fibre content and cure retained per batch; axial mechanical properties per project, third-party where needed.

Pultrusion line: reinforcement from the creels through the impregnation bath, heated die, pullers and cut-off

LFT-D

High-volume, highly integrated thermoplastic functional parts go this way: the ones where ribs, snap fits and inserts have to grow out of a single moulding.

LFT-D is a direct compounding route: the long fibre thermoplastic is compounded, plasticised and moulded in line, so fibre length and dispersion stay under control. We have run PA, PP, PPS and PEEK. The gains are recyclability, reprocessing and a short cycle; the cost is temperature resistance below thermoset.

Fibre length is held back by the screw and the flow path and never reaches continuous fibre; at high fibre content the melt flows poorly, so a thin wall over a long flow path is out; tooling is expensive and small batches do not pay; the temperature ceiling sits below epoxy and polyurethane.

Before the mould is cut: fix wall thickness and the flow-length ratio; keep the gate off high-stress zones and off appearance faces; work out where weld lines land and what they cost in strength; settle draft and ejector position together.

Dimensions and appearance at first-off, then sampled; fibre length and dispersion by burn-off or microscopy; mechanical properties sampled per batch.

LFT-D: matrix pellets and reinforcing fibre fed into stage-1 extrusion and stage-2 compounding, then insulated transport of the blank and compression moulding

Send the drawing. We will send the route.

A drawing, a photo of a failed part, or three lines of requirement is enough to start. Scope, price indication and lead time within 24 hours.

No commitment · NDA available · Reply within 24 hours

Request a quote WhatsApp