Two tubes on the same bench

Same diameter, same finish, same weight in the hand. One is pulled off a continuous line through a die; the other is laid ply by ply on a mandrel. They are not interchangeable. The difference does not show in a photograph; it shows under load. On the same shelf they are the easiest pair of products to mistake for interchangeable stock.

Decide first, then talk process

Constant section, long, part-to-part identical: pultrusion. Hoop strength, taper, a section that is not standard: roll wrapping. Most parts declare themselves in one line of the drawing — a taper or a bend and one of the two processes is out. When the decision stalls, the drawing usually gives the shape but not the load direction or the batch. Supply those two and the answer arrives on its own.

Pultrusion: fibre in one direction

Roving comes off the creel, passes through the resin bath, into a heated die. The resin cures, the puller advances, the profile is cut to length. Every fibre in the tube runs along the axis. That single fact is both the strength and the ceiling: it bends well along its length, and there is almost no fibre to carry hoop stress or torsion. Within a batch, one length is indistinguishable from the next; the section is set by the die. That is why it is sold as a stock profile.

Roll wrapping: the ply angle follows the load

Prepreg goes onto the mandrel ply by ply, each angle chosen for the load: axial plies for bending, ±45° for torsion. After cure the mandrel comes out. Thin walls need no matched tool, so one diameter, one taper, one small batch is cheap here — this is the moulding route. The cost is that every lay-up change has to be verified again; it cannot be swapped like a stock profile.

Where they differ

Pultruded Roll wrapped
Axial stiffness High, set by the die Set by the axial plies
Hoop and torsion Weak Set by the ±45° plies
Wall consistency From the die, part to part From the lay-up, part to part varies
Cost against volume Spread over metres; longer is cheaper Spread over parts; falls slowly with volume

When only roll wrapping will do

Tapered tube, a non-round or non-standard section, a driveshaft that is mostly torsion. A pultruded section cannot change along its length; if the drawing demands that it does, the process is decided before the quotation. Parts that have to insulate meet the same fork in glass fibre.

One more case: a large-diameter, short cylinder. A mandrel is cheaper than a die that size, so that also goes to roll wrapping.

When pultrusion is cheaper

Long, straight, constant section, repeat order. The tool is a single die, amortised over metres rather than parts, so the unit price falls with length. A straight tube plus a real quantity is usually the cheapest route — carbon and glass fibre tube, both run in our plant: tube sizes we make.

The other side of it: that price depends on the shape staying put. Add holes, cut-outs or a diameter change and the saving is eaten downstream. Count it in the total, not in the tube price.

Where each one stops

Pultrusion cannot make a varying section or a bend. If the design needs one, the process changes — and finding that out at sample stage is expensive.

In roll wrapping, wall consistency depends on the person laying up. How well it holds depends on who is at the bench: same person, same bench, same result. We say it plainly — it is a part made by hand, and consistency has to be managed as a human variable, a scheduling problem as much as a technical one.

There is a limit in length too. A single length is not as long as you like; pulling and shipping set the ceiling. Beyond it the part is joined, and a joint is a new weak point.

What to send

Section, length, quantity, load direction. With those four the route is usually obvious, and the reply states the conclusion rather than the options.

For sizing the tube, see How to size a carbon fibre tube.

Need a manufacturability review? Start an RFQ