Dielectric Case study

They asked for 97%, 95% was the part that worked.

The customer's RF transmission requirement read “95% to 99%, the higher the better,” but named no single threshold.

Our initial design was clean: cyanate ester resin with glass fibre, 0.5 mm wall. A flat coupon measured 97% transmission across 2.4–8 GHz in customer testing. Light, cost-effective, and every figure within range.

Halfway through the presentation, the real problem surfaced.

A coupon does not take that hit for the product

The RF-transparent face sits on top of the machine; the battery sits underneath. To change the battery, the operator turns the whole machine over so that face rests directly on the ground — and not gently: the machine is dragged across concrete. The previous housing was 2.5 mm PA6 and survived that use. A 0.5 mm glass-fibre shell, used this way, would not last many cycles.

The coupon was not wrong. A coupon simply does not take that hit for the product.

No datasheet says, “this face gets dragged on the ground.” The customer did not mention it; we did not ask.

97% coupon versus 95% production part
Left: the 0.5 mm design, 97% — verified on a flat coupon only. Right: the 2 mm design, 95% — three years in service. Below: the machine is turned over to change the battery, and the RF face is dragged on the floor.

Back to 2 mm, and the spec comes down

The design changed: 2 mm glass fibre with epoxy, ≥95% transmission in the same band, customer-tested. A thicker wall required one grade down in material — cyanate ester to epoxy — and total cost, including tooling and testing, came out about 30% below the 0.5 mm design. A few hundred grams heavier, still within the machine's allowable range. Three years in service, no problems.

Those two points

We had spent effort pushing 95% to 97%, only to find those two points were worth nothing from the start. What decided the design was not the number but an action nobody had written into the specification: turn the machine over and drag it across the floor.

Now we ask three questions before any design discussion: Where does this part sit? Who touches it? How do they touch it?

The specification tells you what a part has to meet. The use case tells you what it has to survive.

Send the drawing. We will send the route.

A drawing, a photo of a failed part, or three lines of requirement is enough to start. Scope, price indication and lead time within 24 hours.

No commitment · NDA available · Reply within 24 hours

Request a quote WhatsApp